Starship Returns

Eric Berger had a short essay about the feat:

https://arstechnica.com/space/2026/11/with-starship-catch-spacex-still-shows-it-can-dazzle-the-world/

Just a coupla thoughts from me:
 
One thing is that Spacex has decided to ditch the Falcon 9 rocket in the near future.  Think of a Falcon 9 as a pickup truck to space.  Pickups are perfect for moving your sister's stuff across town to her new apartment.  So the Falcon 9 was perfect for launching relatively small satellites.  More lift capability was had by joining three Falcon 9 rockets together for a Falcon Heavy if needed.  But with the demise of Falcon 9, lots of customers won't be able to launch their junk into space as easily.

Starship with Booster isn't a pickup, more like an 18 wheeler.  And in effect, Starship is the replacement for the Falcon 9 - this is as if Ford had replaced the Model T with that 18 wheeler.  Some jobs just aren't sized for an 18 wheeler.  If your sister lived on a narrow street with lots of trees and lots of cars an 18 wheeler is NG.  Similarly, to land a Starship on the moon and get astronauts up and down from well over 100 feet will be quite a trick, even in the 1/6 gravity of the moon.

As I understand it, catching a Starship and Booster with the launch tower (really quite a feat) was driven by the fact that landing legs of appropriate size for either Starship or Booster would have used too much mass.  BUT to land a Starship on the moon will surely require legs won't it ?

Spacex has taken current technology to the limit and beyond.  But this approach doesn't solve all needs.  Hopefully other companies will have different approaches that fill in where Starship isn't appropriate.

Best Regards,
Chuck, WB9KZY
http://wb9kzy.com/ham.htm



Comments